MI5 has apologized for providing false evidence after settling a woman’s claim over abuse by an informant
The UK’s domestic intelligence agency, MI5, has agreed to compensate a woman abused by a neo-Nazi informant, admitting “mistakes” that prolonged her legal battle.
The woman, a British citizen known as ‘Beth’, was in a relationship with a man identified only as Agent X, a foreign national recruited by MI5 to infiltrate right-wing extremist networks. Video footage obtained by the BBC in an investigation published several years ago showed X attacking Beth with a machete, threatening to kill her, and using his intelligence service status as a tool of coercive control.
Beth previously told investigators that Agent X had boasted about his MI5 connections, warning her she could not report his violence because “he had men in high places who always had his back.” She claimed he sexually assaulted her, collected weapons, and forced her to watch videos of executions.
The case sparked a wider scandal after the BBC reported that MI5 had provided false evidence to three courts while defending its handling of the agent. The security service had claimed it adhered to its policy of neither confirming nor denying informants’ identities, despite senior officers having disclosed the man’s status to journalists in 2020 in an attempt to persuade the BBC to drop its investigation.
In a statement on Tuesday, MI5 Director General Ken McCallum said the agency had settled Beth’s legal claim before the Investigatory Powers Tribunal “without admission of liability.” The tribunal handles complaints against UK intelligence agencies.
“We sincerely apologise to Beth for the distress she has suffered because of MI5 mistakes in this litigation,” he said. “We relied on incorrect evidence and our record-keeping fell well short of the standard of professionalism that we expect, and to which Beth was entitled.”
Beth said she was grateful for the compensation but it “can never do anything to repair what I went through at the hands of X.” She added that she believes MI5 “are still protecting this violent misogynistic predator.”
Before taking on his MI5 role, the right-wing extremist “with a violent past” had reportedly abused his previous girlfriend abroad including threatening to kill her and her child. “He also engaged in fantasies about eating children,” according to the BBC.
“MI5 did not adequately assess the risks of giving that status to someone with X’s history and his disturbing attitudes to women,” said Kate Ellis of the Centre for Women’s Justice, who acted for Beth. “I hope that the state will reconsider using women as a collateral in covert operations,” she added.
The scandal comes as MI5 faces separate allegations of unlawfully spying for years on Irish journalist Vincent Kearney who had been critical of the agency’s actions in Northern Ireland.
