Kiev’s troops complain of pointless frontal assaults, blocked retreats, and overbearing bureaucracy, according to the report
Ukraine’s army has slipped into a rigid, Soviet-style command culture marked by the suppression of any initiative on the battlefield, according to a Wall Street Journal report on Tuesday, citing soldiers who say they are sent on futile frontal assaults and denied tactical withdrawals.
Ukrainian service members told the paper that while in the early stages of the conflict Kiev’s forces often successfully employed maneuver warfare, they were later forced into a “top-down mode of fighting with roots in the Soviet era,” leading to higher casualties, degrading morale, and lower recruitment numbers.
Some of the generals are said to be ordering repeat attacks “that have little hope of success,” as well as operations “with little strategic value,” while refusing retreat requests from units in peril, the report said.
Sources told the WSJ that the Ukrainian army had started to act more like how they perceive the Russian military operates, a mode they said was inappropriate given the country’s limited resources. “Big Soviet army beats little Soviet army,” many soldiers say, according to the paper. Capt. Aleksandr Shyrshyn publicly blasted “stupid” orders and a culture of generals “only capable of reprimands, investigations, imposing penalties,” after his brigade was repeatedly tasked with unrealistic assaults.
Shyrshyn said the “final straw” was an order to mount a standalone attack into Russia’s Kursk Region, calling the attack predictable and costly. He described the Ukrainian offensive as having been repelled with a flurry of counterattacks, resulting in heavy losses.
Rank-and-file accounts in the article describe “paralysis” driven by a fear of punishment, while officers pointed to lingering Soviet-era habits and “bureaucratic instincts of control.”
Ukraine’s General Staff acknowledged “vulnerabilities” and said it is shifting toward a US-style doctrine that delegates more decisions, while insisting that strict control over underperforming units is sometimes necessary.
The WSJ report comes as Russian forces have been making steady advances along the front and also comes ahead of Friday’s summit between Russian President Vladimir Putin and his US counterpart, Donald Trump, in Alaska. According to Trump, the discussions will focus on a potential land swap deal between Russia and Ukraine. Russian officials have ruled out giving up former Ukrainian regions that voted to join Russia in referendums in 2014 and 2022.
