The critics of the initiative have slammed the facilities as detention centers located in “legal black holes”
European lawmakers have endorsed the opening of talks with the EU Council on a new controversial legal framework to establish block-wide mechanisms to expel illegal migrants, including creating the so-called “return hubs” located in third countries.
The idea to create de facto detention facilities outside of the EU’s borders to hold migrants deemed to have no right to stay within the bloc has been opposed by rights groups and pro-migration political forces. Under the proposed Return Regulation, which is still in early stages of the legislative process, people marked for deportation in the EU will be sent off to overseas “return hubs” rather than stay within the bloc awaiting expulsion. Critics are insisting the scheme is intended to disappear irregular migrants and failed asylum seekers into a “legal black hole.”
The proposed reform went on the plenary vote on Thursday after three left-wing political groups, namely the S&D, the Greens/EFA, and the Left, had separately filed requests for it. The groups sought to challenge a decision made by the Civil Liberties Committee earlier this month, when the body approved the proposed legislation to enter into interinstitutional negotiations. The attempt flopped, with 389 MEPs voting in favor of proceeding to the next stage of the legislative process with the proposal, while 206 voted against and 32 abstained.
The outcome of the vote has been strongly condemned by multiple human rights groups that accused right-wing and anti-migration parties of pushing through a purportedly poorly thought-out initiative.
Amnesty International’s European institutions director, Eve Geddie, for instance, said the proposed reform had not received “adequate scrutiny or meaningful human rights assessments.”
“This marks a growing trend towards increasingly harmful, exclusionary, and draconian policies on migration, with worrying repercussions for due process and evidence-based policymaking. Far from reducing irregularity, these proposals risk trapping more people in precarious situations,” she said in a statement.
The Return Regulation was proposed in March last year, meant to replace the 2008 Return Directive, which prioritized the “voluntary return” of illegal migrants and failed asylum seekers. In December 2025, 19 EU member states urged the European Commission to help fund “return hubs” outside the bloc, describing them as “innovative solutions” to address the migrant influx, which has been plaguing the bloc for over a decade.
